Overall Score: 6.4 The Peat Monster is a balanced whisky with moderate smokiness and great flavors. However, it lacks bolder flavors offered by competitors in the peat market. Your palate will be the decider on this one.
Overall Score: 7.2 Compass Box The Spice Tree is a unique expression offering rich flavors from the oak cask maturation. The spice builds on your palate for a great experience.
Overall Score: 7.2 Compass Box The Spaniard offers unique flavors, which benefit from a sherry cask finish. This is a solid scotch that proves its value for the $70 price.